Only 5% of your future customers are buying right now. Here's what that means for UK SME owners, and how to fix your marketing split without blowing your cash flow.
Right now, about 95% of the businesses that will one day buy from you aren't buying anything. Not from you, not from your competitors. They're busy, they're sorted, and your ad is wallpaper to them.
Yet most small business marketing is built as if the opposite were true. Every pound goes on catching the handful of people searching today, and every campaign gets judged on whether the phone rang this fortnight.
That's the trap the 95:5 rule exposes. If you've watched your cost per lead creep up quarter after quarter, it explains more about your numbers than any agency report you'll read this year.
What is the 95:5 rule?
The 95:5 rule says only around 5% of your potential buyers are in the market at any given time; the other 95% won't buy for months or even years. It comes from research by Professor John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science, published by Peter Weinberg and Jon Lombardo of LinkedIn's B2B Institute in Marketing Week under the headline "The 95:5 rule is the new 60:40 rule".
The practical point is blunt. You can't persuade someone into the market. A business that switched accountants last year isn't switching again because your ad was clever.
As Dawes puts it, buyers "largely use their memories when buying, rather than searching". And the ones who do search "strongly prefer brands they're familiar with". Marketing's real job is to be the name that comes to mind when the need finally arrives.
THE HARD TRUTH: Most marketing doesn't fail because the ads are bad. It fails because it's aimed at people who aren't buying, then judged as if they were.
Why is it called "the new 60:40 rule"?
Because it's designed to change how marketers budget, the way Les Binet and Peter Field's 60:40 rule did. Their IPA research, The Long and the Short of It, found brands generally performed best with about 60% of spend on long-term brand building and 40% on short-term sales activation.
Their follow-up for the B2B Institute, The 5 Principles of Growth in B2B Marketing, found B2B firms grow best with 46% on brand and 54% on activation. The 95:5 rule supplies the reason: most of the people you reach simply aren't ready yet.
| The 60:40 rule (Binet & Field, IPA) |
The 95:5 rule (Dawes, Ehrenberg-Bass / B2B Institute) |
|
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A budget guideline: roughly 60% brand building, 40% sales activation (46:54 in B2B) | A market reality: about 5% of buyers are in-market now, 95% are not |
| The question it answers | How should I split my spend? | Who am I actually talking to? |
| Built on | Effectiveness data from IPA campaign case studies | Purchase-cycle maths and buyer research |
| The mistake it fixes | Over-spending on short-term sales activation | Judging all marketing on next-fortnight sales |
| What it means for an SME | Don't put every pound into capturing demand | Build memory now, so you're on the shortlist later |
60:40 tells you how to split the money. 95:5 tells you why the split exists.The maths every SME owner should run
The 95:5 rule isn't a slogan; it's arithmetic you can do on the back of a beer mat. Dawes' worked example used business banking: companies switch banks roughly once every five years.
Spread evenly, that's about 20% of businesses in the market in any 12 months, about 2% in a month and roughly 1% in the next fortnight. Now put it on your own patch. Say there are 1,000 businesses across North Hampshire that could use your service, and they change supplier about once every five years.
| Time window | Share in-market | Of 1,000 businesses in your patch (switching about every 5 years) |
|---|---|---|
| Next 12 months | About 20% | About 200 |
| Next quarter | About 5% | About 50 |
| Next month | About 2% | About 20 |
| Next two weeks | About 1% | About 10 |
Judge a campaign on two weeks of sales and you're judging it on about 10 businesses, shared with every competitor bidding for them.
Ten businesses. That's your realistic two-week pool, and you share it with every rival bidding on the same keywords. The B2B Institute calls this "a low ceiling on your short-term sales potential".
Does the 95:5 rule apply to consumers too?
Yes, the principle does, but the 5% figure doesn't transfer directly. Dawes' 5% is a B2B number, built on how rarely businesses switch suppliers. The idea underneath it comes from Ehrenberg-Bass's consumer research: Byron Sharp's How Brands Grow and Jenni Romaniuk's work on mental availability, which describes buyers who "easily think of the brand when buying".
Most people aren't in the market for most things, most of the time. What changes is how many are in-market at once, and that depends on how often your customers buy:
• Rare purchases (boilers, kitchens, conveyancing, cars, wedding photography): the in-market share is often smaller than 5%. A homeowner who replaces a boiler roughly every 12 years is in the market for less than 1% of any given month. Being remembered matters even more here.
• Mid-frequency purchases (dentists, gyms, hairdressers, insurance renewals): these behave much like B2B, with a yearly trigger and a strong pull towards the familiar name.
• Frequent purchases (coffee, takeaways, groceries): most people are in the market every week. The fight isn't about timing; it's about being the default. Easy to find, easy to remember, easy to buy.
So whether you sell to businesses, homeowners or both, the job is the same: be known before the need arrives. Only the numbers on the beer mat change.
Why fighting over the 5% keeps getting more expensive
When every business piles onto the same small pool of in-market buyers, the auction does what auctions do: the price goes up. WordStream's 2025 Google Ads benchmarks found the average cost per click rose 12.88% year on year, with increases in 87% of industries. Average cost per lead climbed to $70.11 (US data, but UK advertisers bid in the same auctions on the same logic).
Meanwhile, buyers are making up their minds before they ever reach you. 6sense's 2025 study of more than 4,000 B2B buyers found 94% had ranked their preferred suppliers before contacting any of them. They then bought from that early favourite 77% of the time.
Put those together. Only 5% are buying, most of them already have a favourite, and the rest cost more to reach every year. If nobody knew your name before their buying window opened, you're bidding for scraps.
THE HARD TRUTH: Search ads don't create demand. They charge you rent on demand someone else created, usually your best-known competitor.
How big agencies trained everyone to chase the 5%
I spent 15+ years inside WPP, Omnicom and Dentsu networks, and the problem was rarely the budget. It was the reporting rhythm. Weekly dashboards reward whatever moves this week: clicks, leads, return on ad spend.
Brand work rarely moves anything inside a week. So when a quarter looked shaky, it was the first line to get cut, even on accounts with millions behind them.
SMEs inherit the same habit in miniature. A Google Ads account, a monthly report, a cost per lead, and a vague guilt about "doing more on social". The outcome is identical: all the budget fighting for the 5%, none of it building memory with the 95%.
Attribution makes it worse. Last-click reporting hands the sale to the search ad, even when the buyer chose you because of a LinkedIn post six months ago, a referral, or your van parked outside their unit every Tuesday.
Does the 95:5 rule mean I should stop running Google Ads?
No. The 5% still need catching, and search is still the cleanest way to catch them. The rule says don't spend everything there, and don't judge the rest of your marketing by search-style metrics.
| Harvesting the 5% | Building memory with the 95% | |
|---|---|---|
| The job | Catch buyers who are searching right now | Be the name they think of when they start looking |
| Typical channels | Google Search ads, retargeting, comparison sites | Google Business Profile, reviews, LinkedIn, Meta reach campaigns, email, local PR and sponsorship |
| Measure it by | Cost per lead, conversion rate, ROAS | Reach in your area, branded searches, direct enquiries, "how did you hear about us?" |
| Payback | Days to weeks | Months to years |
| Cost trend | Rising, as more bidders chase the same buyers | Cheaper per person reached, and it compounds |
| Risk if it's all you do | Rising acquisition costs and a pipeline that stops when the ads stop | A cash-flow gap while memory builds |
You need both columns. Most SMEs only fund the left one.
If you want a practical way to plan that split before you spend a penny, the Plan Before You Spend playbook in my playbook library walks you through it step by step.
The 95:5 playbook for lean teams
You don't need a big-brand TV budget to market to the 95%. You need a tighter search account, cheap local reach and the patience to measure the right things. Here's how to do it with a lean team:
1. Size your 5%. Work out how often your customers buy or switch, and how many could buy from you in your area. Divide to get a realistic in-market number per month. That's the ceiling on your short-term results.
2. Keep search tight, not fat. Fund Google Ads for the high-intent terms that actually convert, and cut broad terms that burn cash. Every pound you save funds the 95%.
3. Write for the moment buyers enter the market. Ehrenberg-Bass calls these category entry points: the triggers that start a search, such as a new hire, a year end, a failed boiler or a bad experience with a current supplier. Build your content and ads around those moments, not your service list.
4. Be distinctive, then be consistent. Same colours, same logo, same tone of voice, everywhere, for years. Memory is built on repetition, not novelty.
5. Buy cheap reach in your patch. Run Meta and LinkedIn campaigns optimised for reach in a tight radius, keep your Google Business Profile fresh, and post every week. The goal is to reach as many of your 1,000 as possible, not the same 50 people on repeat.
6. Build a list you own. A regular email or newsletter keeps you in front of the 95% for pennies, and no algorithm can switch it off.
7. Measure memory, not just leads. Track branded searches in Google Search Console, direct enquiries and Google Business Profile views, and add "How did you hear about us?" to every enquiry form. Review these quarterly, not weekly.
8. Set a split your cash flow can stomach. Binet and Field's B2B work points to roughly 46% brand, 54% activation. You don't have to start there. My advice for a cash-tight SME: put 20-30% of spend into reaching the 95%, then grow it as the memory metrics move.
Every Monday, The Growth Ledger breaks down changes like this for local business owners in a five-minute read. You can sign up here
THE HARD TRUTH: If your enquiries stop the day you pause your ads, you never built a brand. You were renting one.
The bottom line
The 95:5 rule doesn't ask you to spend more. It asks you to stop spending everything in the same place. Catch the 5% efficiently, then put a deliberate slice of your budget into being remembered by the 95% before they need you.
The businesses that do this quietly become the default choice in their area. The ones that don't keep paying a bit more each year for the same ten buyers.
Find out how much of your budget is chasing the 5%
That's exactly what my Free Digital Audit is built to show. I'll review your current online activity, from Google Ads and SEO to social and your Google Business Profile, and show you how much of your spend is fighting over the in-market few and where cheap reach could start building memory with everyone else.
You get a written report with a clear strategy and key focus areas, plus a walkthrough call with an ex-global agency director. No fluff, no pitch, and I reply within 2 working days. I only run a limited number each month, so Request your Free Digital Audit
Sources
• Weinberg, P. & Lombardo, J. (2021) "The 95:5 rule is the new 60:40 rule", Marketing Week, 2 Sept 2021: https://www.marketingweek.com/peter-weinberg-jon-lombardo-95-5-rule
• Ehrenberg-Bass Institute republication of the same article: https://marketingscience.info/news-and-insights/the-955-rule-is-the-new-6040-rule
• Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, "The 95:5 Rule: Why B2B Growth Starts Long Before the Purchase" (Prof. John Dawes): https://marketingscience.info/news-and-insights/the-955-rule-why-b2b-growth-starts-long-before-the-purchase
• LinkedIn B2B Institute (2019), "How B2B marketing really drives growth" (Binet & Field, 46% brand / 54% activation): https://business.linkedin.com/en-uk/marketing-solutions/blog/posts/B2B-Marketing/2019/How-B2B-marketing-really-drives-growth
• IPA, The Long and the Short of It (Binet & Field) - VERIFY: the 60:40 split is widely cited from this report but isn't stated on the IPA summary page I opened: https://ipa.co.uk/knowledge/publications-reports/the-long-and-the-short-of-it-balancing-short-and-long-term-marketing-strategies/
• 6sense (12 Nov 2025), 2025 Buyer Experience Report press release: 94% rank vendors before first contact, 77% buy from the favourite, 4,000+ buyers: https://6sense.com/newsroom/the-timeline-for-influencing-b2b-buyers-is-shrinking-insights-from-6senses-2025-buyer-experience-report/
• Ehrenberg-Bass Institute / Marketing Facts, "How do you measure How Brands Grow?" (mental availability and category entry points, Romaniuk and Sharp) - secondary summary, verify the quote against Romaniuk's Better Brand Health if you want to cite the book directly: https://marketingscience.info/how-do-you-measure-how-brands-grow/
• WordStream (2025), Google Ads Benchmarks: CPC +12.88%, 87% of industries, $70.11 CPL (US campaigns, Apr 2024-Mar 2025): https://www.wordstream.com/blog/2025-google-ads-benchmarks